Back to Blog

When should I get pet insurance?

Financial Toolset Team4 min read

Get it when your pet is young (under 2 years old). Premiums are lower, and there are no pre-existing conditions to exclude. Waiting until your pet is older or sick means higher premiums and coverag...

When should I get pet insurance?

Listen to this article

Browser text-to-speech

When Should I Get Pet Insurance?

Bringing a pet into your home is an exciting and rewarding experience, but it also comes with a new set of responsibilities. One of the most important decisions you'll face is whether or not to get pet insurance, and if so, when. Timing can significantly impact the cost and coverage of your policy, making it a crucial consideration for any pet owner.

Why Timing Matters

The optimal time to purchase pet insurance is immediately after bringing your pet home, ideally within the first six months of adoption. This timing strategy not only ensures lower premiums but also maximizes coverage benefits by avoiding pre-existing condition exclusions.

  • Young Pets: Starting premiums are lower when pets are young and healthy. For example, a dog enrolled at three months old might have a monthly premium of $35.11, whereas a cat at the same age might cost around $22.45.
  • Older Pets: As pets age, premiums can increase dramatically. By the time a dog reaches 12 years old, the monthly premium could skyrocket to $156.59, and for a 14-year-old cat, it could reach $107.09. This steep increase can make delaying enrollment an expensive decision.

Pre-Existing Conditions

Any health issue that arises before your policy's start date is considered a pre-existing condition and typically won't be covered by pet insurance. This is a significant financial risk if your pet develops health issues before you secure coverage.

Waiting Periods

Most pet insurance policies come with waiting periods—usually a few days for accidents and a couple of weeks for illnesses—before the coverage kicks in. Enrolling your pet early ensures that you can access insurance benefits as soon as possible after adoption.

Real-World Financial Impact

To illustrate, consider the difference in lifetime costs for a dog enrolled at three months versus six years old. The younger pet's monthly premium of $35.11 translates to approximately $421 annually. In contrast, the six-year-old's premium of $48.34 per month results in $580 annually—a 38% increase for identical coverage. Over a 12-year period, this difference compounds significantly, making early enrollment a financially savvy choice.

Pet's AgeMonthly PremiumAnnual Cost
3 Months$35.11$421
6 Years$48.34$580

Common Mistakes and Considerations

Delaying Enrollment

One common mistake is waiting until your pet develops health issues before purchasing insurance. This delay can lead to higher premiums and limited coverage due to pre-existing conditions. By enrolling early, you lock in lower rates and broader coverage.

Age Restrictions

Some insurance companies impose upper age limits for enrollment. While options like Pumpkin offer coverage for pets over 12 years old, it's essential to check specific company policies if your pet is older.

Premium Escalation Risk

While enrolling early locks in lower initial rates, be aware that premiums will typically increase annually as your pet ages. This escalation can make costs prohibitive later, so consider your long-term budget when deciding on coverage.

Bottom Line

From a financial planning perspective, purchasing pet insurance within six months of adoption—ideally immediately—is the best approach to minimize lifetime costs and maximize coverage eligibility. Delaying significantly increases both premiums and the risk of exclusions due to pre-existing conditions. By acting early, you ensure that your pet is protected, and you safeguard yourself from unexpected financial burdens down the road.

Try the Calculator

Ready to take control of your finances?

Calculate your personalized results.

Launch Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the When should I get pet insurance?

Get it when your pet is young (under 2 years old). Premiums are lower, and there are no pre-existing conditions to exclude. Waiting until your pet is older or sick means higher premiums and coverag...