Back to Blog

What warranties are worth buying?

Financial Toolset Team4 min read

Manufacturer warranties typically cover 1 year (longer for compressors/heat exchangers). Extended warranties can help for high‑cost, complex systems (HVAC) but often aren’t worth it for small appli...

What warranties are worth buying?

Listen to this article

Browser text-to-speech

Deciphering Warranties: Which Ones Are Worth Your Investment?

When it comes to warranties, the decision to invest often boils down to peace of mind versus cost. But not all warranties offer the same value. Whether you're considering protection for your home appliances or systems, understanding which warranties are worth buying can save you money and headaches down the road. This article will guide you through the nuances of warranty coverage, helping you make informed decisions.

Understanding Warranties: Home vs. Extended

Home Warranties

Home warranties provide coverage for multiple household systems and appliances under a single plan. They are particularly beneficial for homeowners with aging systems or multiple high-cost items that could malfunction.

Extended Warranties

Extended warranties, on the other hand, cover individual appliances beyond the manufacturer's warranty period. These can be worthwhile for high-cost, high-risk items that are expensive to repair.

  • Cost-Effectiveness: Consider the price of the warranty versus potential repair costs. For instance, an extended warranty on a refrigerator could make sense if repair costs are high and the appliance is nearing the end of its typical 11-year lifespan.
  • Limitations: Often, extended warranties come with exclusions for pre-existing conditions or improper maintenance, so reading the fine print is crucial.

Real-World Examples: Making the Right Choice

Scenario 1: The Older Home

Imagine a homeowner in Texas with a 10-year-old HVAC system, a 9-year-old water heater, and several other aging appliances. Opting for a home warranty like the American Home Shield’s ShieldSilver plan can be advantageous. This plan includes HVAC coverage with a high repair cap of $5,000, safeguarding against potential breakdowns during sweltering summers.

Scenario 2: High-End Appliances

A luxury homeowner with high-end kitchen appliances might lean towards a comprehensive plan from First American Home Warranty. With no caps on HVAC or plumbing repairs and high appliance limits, this warranty provides peace of mind despite higher premiums.

Scenario 3: New Homeowner

Conversely, a buyer of a newly built home filled with brand-new appliances might skip extended warranties altogether. The low risk of early failures and existing manufacturer warranties make additional coverage redundant in this case.

Common Mistakes and Considerations

Assess Appliance Age and Condition

Warranties are most beneficial for appliances nearing or past their average lifespan. For instance, if your dishwasher is approaching its 9-year mark, a warranty might be worth considering.

Read the Fine Print

Coverage exclusions can be numerous, including pre-existing conditions or improper maintenance. Always read the terms carefully to ensure you understand what is covered.

Consider Customer Service and Claims Process

Not all warranty providers offer the same level of service. Look for companies with strong repair guarantees and good customer reviews. The ability to choose your contractor can also be a significant advantage.

Avoid Duplicate Coverage

If an appliance is still covered by the manufacturer's warranty, purchasing an extended warranty might be unnecessary. Always check existing coverage before buying additional protection.

Bottom Line: Key Takeaways

Warranties can be a valuable investment, particularly for older, high-cost systems or appliances with a high risk of failure. When considering a warranty:

  • Evaluate the appliance's age and condition.
  • Compare the costs of potential repairs against the warranty premiums and service fees.
  • Choose a plan with strong coverage limits, good customer service, and clear terms.

For those with older systems or multiple high-value appliances, a comprehensive home warranty can offer peace of mind and financial protection. However, always weigh the costs and benefits carefully to ensure your decision aligns with your personal circumstances and financial goals.

By taking the time to assess your needs and the specific terms of potential warranties, you can make a smart choice that safeguards your home and budget.

Try the Calculator

Ready to take control of your finances?

Calculate your personalized results.

Launch Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the What warranties are worth buying?

Manufacturer warranties typically cover 1 year (longer for compressors/heat exchangers). Extended warranties can help for high‑cost, complex systems (HVAC) but often aren’t worth it for small appli...