Financial Toolset
Insurance & Risk Management

Comprehensive Coverage

Auto insurance that covers damage to your vehicle from non-collision events like theft, vandalism, weather, or animal strikes.

Also known as: comprehensive auto, comp coverage

What You Need to Know

Comprehensive coverage (often called "comp") protects your car from damage not caused by collisions. It's the "other stuff" insuranceโ€”everything except hitting something or rolling over.

What Comprehensive Covers:

  • Theft or attempted theft
  • Vandalism and malicious mischief
  • Weather damage (hail, flood, hurricane, tornado)
  • Falling objects (trees, rocks, debris)
  • Fire and explosions
  • Civil disturbance/riots
  • Animal strikes (deer, moose, etc.)
  • Glass breakage (windshield)

What It Doesn't Cover:

  • Collisions with vehicles or objects (that's collision coverage)
  • Normal wear and tear
  • Mechanical breakdowns
  • Personal belongings inside the car (use homeowners/renters insurance)

Typical Deductibles:

  • $250 (higher premium)
  • $500 (most common)
  • $1,000 (lower premium)

Rate Impact: Comprehensive claims usually cause little to no rate increase (0-10%) because they're not your fault. However, multiple claims can still affect your rates.

Should You Buy It?

Yes if:

  • Your car is worth > $5,000
  • You have a loan/lease (usually required)
  • You live in areas with high theft, hail, or deer
  • You park on the street

Consider dropping if:

  • Car value < $3,000
  • Older vehicle you could afford to replace
  • Annual premium + deductible > 20% of car value

Real Example: Car worth $4,000, comp premium $300/year, $500 deductible. Max payout: $3,500. Over 10 years, you pay $3,000 in premiums. Not worth itโ€”drop coverage and self-insure.

Sources & References

This information is sourced from authoritative government and academic institutions:

  • naic.org

    https://www.naic.org/consumer.htm