Back to Blog

When does a side hustle make sense vs overtime?

Financial Toolset Team4 min read

Compare effective hourly rates. If overtime pays 1.5x with no extra overhead, it may beat a low‑margin side hustle. Side hustles shine when scalable, skill‑building, or offering strong margins.

When does a side hustle make sense vs overtime?

Listen to this article

Browser text-to-speech

When Does a Side Hustle Make Sense vs. Overtime?

Choosing between pursuing a side hustle or working overtime can significantly impact your financial situation and overall well-being. While both options provide additional income, they cater to different needs and circumstances. This article will help you decide when a side hustle makes more financial sense compared to working overtime.

Comparing Income Potential

Overtime Pay:

  • Workers with access to overtime typically earn 1.5x to 2x their regular hourly rate.
  • Overtime offers predictability. If you work an extra 10 hours at a $20/hour rate with 1.5x overtime pay, you earn an additional $300.

Side Hustle Earnings:

  • Side hustlers earn an average of $885 per month, but the median is much lower at $200.
  • Earnings vary widely; 28% of side hustlers make only $1 to $50 monthly.

Real-World Example

Consider Alex and Jamie, both making $20/hour. Alex has the chance to work 10 hours of overtime weekly, earning an extra $300. Jamie, on the other hand, starts a side hustle selling handmade crafts. Initially, Jamie invests $100 in materials and spends 10 hours weekly on the business. In the first month, Jamie earns $400 in sales, netting $300 after costs.

Key Takeaway: In the short term, Alex's overtime earnings are predictable and immediate, while Jamie's side hustle offers potential growth but requires initial investment and time to scale.

When Each Option Makes Sense

Overtime Is Preferable When:

Side Hustles Are Preferable When:

Critical Trade-offs

Consider Health and Lifestyle:

  • Overtime can lead to chronic fatigue, increased absenteeism, and health issues over time.
  • Side hustles require self-discipline, initial investment, and time management but offer flexibility.

Financial Health Perspective:

  • Workers combining traditional jobs with side hustles often score higher in financial health than those relying solely on gig work.

Common Mistakes and Considerations

Bottom Line

Deciding between a side hustle and overtime depends on your financial goals, available time, health considerations, and long-term aspirations. Overtime is ideal for immediate, guaranteed income, especially if your employer offers competitive rates. However, a side hustle can be a smart choice if you have marketable skills, seek flexibility, and are willing to invest time and effort for potential growth.

Ultimately, a strategic combination of both can offer the best of both worlds, providing immediate financial relief through overtime while building a side hustle for future financial flexibility. Evaluate your situation, weigh the pros and cons, and choose the path that aligns best with your personal and financial goals.

Try the Calculator

Ready to take control of your finances?

Calculate your personalized results.

Launch Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the When does a side hustle make sense vs overtime?

Compare effective hourly rates. If overtime pays 1.5x with no extra overhead, it may beat a low‑margin side hustle. Side hustles shine when scalable, skill‑building, or offering strong margins.
When does a side hustle make sense vs overtime? | FinToolset