Back to Blog

Should I focus on debt payoff or investing?

Financial Toolset Team5 min read

Pay off debt above 7-8% APR before investing (except 401(k) match). Below 4-5%, consider investing instead as stock market historically returns 7-10%. For 5-7% debt, it's personal—pay off high-rate...

Should I focus on debt payoff or investing?

Listen to this article

Browser text-to-speech

Should I Focus on Debt Payoff or Investing?

Deciding between paying off debt and investing can feel like walking a financial tightrope. Both are crucial for financial health, yet they pull your resources in different directions. The good news? This decision isn't necessarily a binary one. With a little strategy and understanding of your financial landscape, you can find a balance that works best for you.

The Debt Payoff vs. Investing Decision

When deciding whether to pay off debt or invest, consider three main factors: the interest rate on your debt, your risk tolerance, and your financial timeline. The "rule of 6%" is a helpful starting point: prioritize paying down debt with an interest rate of 6% or higher before investing. Why? Because high-interest debt compounds quickly, making it difficult to achieve a higher return on investments.

Key Facts and Statistics

Real-World Scenarios

High-Interest Debt Priority

High-interest debts, like credit card balances with rates around 20%, should be your top priority. Paying these off gives you a guaranteed return equivalent to the interest rate, which is difficult to achieve consistently in the stock market.

Example: If you have a $5,000 credit card balance at 20% interest, that's $1,000 in annual interest. By paying it off, you effectively 'earn' a 20% return, risk-free.

Low-Interest Debt with an Emergency Fund

If your debt has a low interest rate (under 6%), and you have an emergency fund established, investing might be a smarter choice. This scenario allows your money to potentially grow in value over time.

Example: Consider a $10,000 student loan at 4% interest. If you invest instead and achieve a 7% return, your net gain is 3%, making investing a more lucrative option.

Common Considerations

Risk Tolerance

Investing involves uncertainty and market fluctuations. If you're risk-averse, prioritize paying down debt, as it provides a guaranteed return by eliminating interest costs.

Financial Security Impact

If debt is straining your finances or impacting your credit score, prioritize paying it off. This approach can enhance your financial security and improve your creditworthiness.

Time Horizon

If you're planning for long-term goals (10 years or more), investing in a balanced portfolio can offer substantial growth. However, if you need funds sooner, reducing debt might offer more immediate benefits.

The Balanced Approach

Many financial advisors advocate for a balanced strategy, where you allocate extra funds to both debt payoff and investing. This way, you mitigate the risks of high-interest debt while not missing out on potential investment growth.

Example: Suppose you have $300 extra each month. You could allocate $200 towards a high-interest credit card and invest the remaining $100 in a retirement account. This strategy helps reduce debt and grows your investment portfolio simultaneously.

Common Mistakes

Bottom Line

The decision between paying off debt and investing depends on several personal factors, including your debt's interest rates, financial goals, and risk tolerance. Prioritize high-interest debt over 6%, but for lower-interest obligations, consider a balanced approach that allows for both debt reduction and investment growth. Always remember to tailor your strategy to fit your unique financial situation for a healthier, more secure financial future.

Try the Calculator

Ready to take control of your finances?

Calculate your personalized results.

Launch Calculator

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the Should I focus on debt payoff or investing?

Pay off debt above 7-8% APR before investing (except 401(k) match). Below 4-5%, consider investing instead as stock market historically returns 7-10%. For 5-7% debt, it's personal—pay off high-rate...
Should I focus on debt payoff or investing? | FinToolset